top of page

Deciding on What Type of Wedding Cake to Have: A Guide to Finding the Perfect Sweet Treat

Your wedding cake is more than just a delicious dessert, it's a centrepiece that adds to the atmosphere of your big day.

From classic tiered cakes to unique dessert tables, the cake you choose reflects your personal style and the theme of your wedding.

But with so many options available, how do you decide what type of wedding cake to have?


In this guide, we’ll walk you through the key considerations to help you select the perfect cake for your celebration, whether you're leaning toward a traditional design or looking to break away from the norm.


Consider Your Wedding Theme and Style

The first step in choosing your wedding cake is to think about your overall wedding theme and style.

Is your wedding formal or casual? Classic or modern?

The cake should complement the atmosphere and theme of your celebration.

  • Traditional Weddings: If you’re planning a traditional wedding with elegant décor, a classic tiered cake with intricate fondant details, piped icing and perhaps a simple floral arrangement could be ideal. A white or ivory cake with delicate lace, pearls, or sugar flowers can add sophistication.

  • Rustic Weddings: For a rustic or barn inspired wedding, consider a naked cake (a cake without frosting on the outside, showing off the layers inside) or a semi-naked cake with soft buttercream frosting. Decorate it with fresh flowers, berries, or greenery to fit the natural, organic feel.

  • Modern Weddings: For a contemporary celebration, bold geometric shapes, metallic accents, or clean, minimalist designs can be a great choice. Think fondant cakes with sharp edges or fondant wrapped cakes adorned with modern art inspired designs or metallic colours like gold or silver.

  • Whimsical or Themed Weddings: If you're having a themed wedding, let your imagination run wild! You can opt for a cake that reflects your theme, whether that’s a vintage inspired cake with lace details for a retro wedding or a cake shaped like your favourite hobby or destination for something more personalised.


Determine Your Flavour Preferences

Once you’ve decided on the look of the cake, the next step is deciding on the flavours.

Wedding cakes are often as much about flavour as they are about design.

Here are a few things to consider when selecting your wedding cake flavours:

  • Classic Flavours: Vanilla, chocolate, and red velvet are always popular choices because they appeal to a wide variety of tastes. These classic flavours also provide a neutral base, allowing you to pair them with different fillings or frostings.

  • Unique Flavours: If you want your cake to stand out, consider unique flavours like salted caramel, lemon, blueberry, almond, or pistachio. These flavours add an exciting twist and could be a great conversation starter.

  • Filling Options: Don’t forget about the filling! While the cake itself is important, fillings such as chocolate ganache, raspberry jam, lemon curd, or cream cheese frosting can elevate the flavour. Consider having different fillings for each tier or layer to offer variety to your guests.

  • Dietary Preferences: Be sure to take your guests' dietary restrictions into account. Many cake makers now offer gluten-free, vegan, or nut-free options, so there’s no need to leave anyone out. You could even create a cake with multiple layers of different flavours to accommodate various preferences.

Wedding cake adorned with smooth buttercream icing and delicate pale-coloured flowers, creating an elegant and timeless look.

Factor in Your Wedding Budget

Wedding cakes can vary significantly in price, depending on the size, design complexity and ingredients.

It’s important to set a budget early on to avoid surprises later in the process.

  • Simple vs. Elaborate Designs: Simple cakes with minimal decorations will generally cost less than elaborate designs that require intricate details or multiple layers. For example, a single tiered cake with a minimalist design will likely be more affordable than a multi-tiered cake with sugar flowers and edible gold accents.

  • Portion Sizes: Be sure to consider how many guests you’re serving. If you’re having a large wedding with hundreds of guests, you might need a multi tiered cake, which will naturally be more expensive. For smaller weddings, a smaller cake with a few tiers or even individual cupcakes may be a cost effective option.

  • Alternative Options: If a traditional cake isn’t in the budget, consider alternatives like a dessert table with cupcakes or macarons. These options can still provide a sweet ending to your meal and offer variety for your guests.


Choose Your Cake Design and Decorations

The design of your cake is one of the most exciting aspects of wedding planning and there are so many options to explore.

Here are some of the most popular cake design styles:

  • Fondant vs. Buttercream: The choice between fondant and buttercream frosting is a major one. Fondant provides a sleek, smooth finish and is great for intricate designs, while buttercream offers a soft, creamy texture and is easier to work with. Both frostings can be flavoured, so the choice largely comes down to your desired aesthetic and taste preferences.

  • Floral Decorations: Flowers are a common cake decoration, but the type of flowers you use can vary. Fresh flowers like roses, peonies, or orchids can be arranged on the cake for a natural, romantic look. Alternatively, sugar flowers, which are crafted from fondant or gum paste, offer a longer lasting option and can be custom designed to match your wedding colours.

  • Geometric and Modern Elements: For a modern look, geometric shapes, metallic accents and bold colour choices can be incorporated into your cake design. Think angular lines, marble finishes or a two toned cake with sharp edges. These designs can make a statement and add sophistication to a contemporary wedding.

  • Personalised Touches: Your cake should reflect your personality as a couple. Consider including meaningful elements, like monograms, personal quotes, or a theme that’s important to you. For instance, if you love travel, you could incorporate small edible landmarks from your favourite destinations.


Don’t Forget About the Cake Topper

While the cake itself is the main attraction, a fun or elegant cake topper can add that final touch.

You can go traditional with a classic bride and groom figurine, or get creative with something unique, like a personalised cake topper featuring your names, a favourite quote, or a meaningful symbol.

For a more natural touch, a floral arrangement or greenery as a topper can tie the cake into your overall wedding décor. If you prefer something more whimsical, toppers shaped like animals, initials, or even favourite hobbies can add charm to your cake.


Consider the Cake Display

How you display your wedding cake is just as important as the cake itself. If you’re going for a larger, multi tiered cake, make sure the cake stand or table complements the overall theme of your wedding.

A rustic wooden stand works well for a barn wedding, while a glass or mirrored cake stand can create a sleek, modern feel.

Also, think about placement. The cake should be easily accessible but also positioned in a way that allows it to shine as a centrepiece.


Choosing the perfect wedding cake is a blend of creativity, practicality and personalisation.

From flavour to design to decoration, every decision should reflect your style as a couple and create a memorable experience for your guests.


Keep in mind your theme, your budget, and your guests' preferences, and don't hesitate to collaborate with your cake maker to create a cake that will leave a lasting impression.

Naked cake decorated with fresh greenery and foliage, creating a rustic and natural look.

No matter which type of cake you decide on, the most important thing is that it’s a reflection of you and it’s sure to be a sweet finale to your big day!


Happy cake planning!


Please take the opportunity to explore the Wedding Cake services included in our supplier list at The UK Wedding Collective. - LuxeCakes and Artisan Bakes and Chelsea Buns

Comments

Rated 0 out of 5 stars.
No ratings yet

Add a rating
bottom of page